Black Egg Yolks Explained: Causes & Safety Concerns

A man is cooking a black egg yolk

Chickens don’t naturally lay eggs with black yolks, so encountering one can raise a flurry of questions and concerns. 

This phenomenon is not actually a result of the egg-laying process itself but rather a series of post-laying events or conditions like the way the egg is stored and how it’s cooked. 

To learn more about the factors causing black egg yolks and how to handle such rare occurrences, read the rest of this blog!

What Causes Black Egg Yolks?

A black egg yolk is usually a sign that something unusual has happened, either in the chicken’s life or during the egg’s handling and storage. Here are some of the most common factors that turn egg yolks black:

  • Diet of the Chicken: Chickens eating foods high in sulfur or iron, like certain vegetables or feeds, can produce darker yolks. Typically, this results in a gray or green tint, but occasionally it might turn the yolk black.
  • Bacterial or Fungal Contamination: If bacteria or fungi enter an egg, possibly through a small crack, they can cause the yolk to turn black. This is more likely when eggs are stored in conditions that encourage microbial growth.
  • Chemical Reactions: High levels of iron in the hen’s diet or in cooking water can react with sulfur in the egg, darkening the yolk. This reaction is more intense than what causes the green ring around overcooked yolks.
  • Age of the Egg: As eggs get older, chemical changes can occur that may darken the yolk. This is rare but can happen if an egg is stored for a long time.

As a lifelong chicken enthusiast, I’ve encountered various egg anomalies, including the rare black yolk. I once had a batch of eggs with unusually dark yolks after introducing a new feed high in iron content. 

Initially, it alarmed me. However, after thorough testing and consultation with a poultry nutritionist, we linked the yolk discoloration directly to the new feed. 

I shared this experience and my findings with fellow chicken enthusiasts in our local community, and it helped ease their worries about similar occurrences.

Is It Safe to Eat a Black Egg Yolk?

Two chicken eggs with black yolks

If the black color of the egg yolk is due to natural factors like the hen’s diet, it’s generally safe to eat. However, if the discoloration is caused by bacterial or fungal contamination, eating the yolk may cause food poisoning.

This means the safety of eating a black egg yolk largely depends on the cause of the discoloration. 

Dietary causes, like high iron or sulfur in the chicken’s feed, don’t typically make the egg unsafe. These yolks may look odd but are usually harmless. 

On the other hand, if contamination is suspected, especially in the absence of a known dietary cause, it’s best to be careful and avoid eating the egg.

When you’re unsure of the cause, it’s always wise to not eat the egg. Food safety should always be a priority, and with eggs, it’s better to be safe than sorry. 

If there’s any doubt about an egg’s freshness or storage conditions, discarding it is still the safest option.

Black Egg Yolk After Boiling: Safe But Unappealing

Black egg yolk after boiling and overcooked

When an egg yolk turns black, grey, or green after boiling, it’s typically due to overcooking. 

According to a study published in ScienceDirect, this change happens when iron from the yolk reacts with sulfur in the white, creating iron sulfide. 

While this reaction alters the egg’s appearance, it doesn’t impact its safety or nutritional content. Eggs with such color changes are safe to eat, though they might be less visually appealing.

For those looking to avoid such outcomes, learning about the cooking process and the underlying science can be quite beneficial. 

Proper cooking techniques can help maintain the yolk’s natural color and enhance its overall presentation.

Pro Tip: To prevent the yolk from darkening, cool the eggs rapidly after cooking. Immediately after boiling, run cold water over the eggs or immerse them in a bowl of ice water.

This rapid cooling halts the cooking process, ensuring the yolks remain beautifully and evenly colored.

Century Eggs: A Culinary Exception

Century eggs on a plate

Unlike the black yolks caused by overcooking or dietary factors, century eggs are a deliberate delicacy from China. Their dark color is a result of a specific preservation process and not an accidental change.

The process of making century eggs is both an art and a science. They are traditionally cured under a blend of ash, tea, slaked lime, salt, and sometimes earth for about three months. 

Today, mass-produced versions often take less than a fortnight to cure, using lye or, in some cases, zinc or lead oxide. However, it’s important to avoid eggs cured with lead oxide due to its toxic nature. 

Duck, chicken, and other poultry eggs can be used for this preservation.

Inarguably, century eggs have a striking appearance: the egg white transforms into a range of colors from golden amber to a translucent black, while the yolk develops soft rings of green, yellow, and gray. 

Their flavor is equally remarkable, similar to ripe blue cheese with a faint ammonia undertone (a strong ammonia scent indicates spoilage). 

These eggs are often served uncooked, either peeled with pickled spring ginger or simmered in congee with salted dried pork.

Despite their odd coloring and odor, which can initially shock the uninitiated, century eggs are a culinary marvel. They’re rich and complex in flavor, with a gelatinous texture in the white and a soft yolk. 

Their preparation in dishes like steamed spinach with garlic or alongside other Chinese preserved eggs showcases their versatility and the depth they add to various cuisines. 

Check out this video for a closer look at a century egg:

Eating China’s 1,000-Year-Old Egg

Can Chickens Lay Eggs With Black Yolks?

It’s highly unusual for chickens to naturally lay eggs with black yolks, just as it is uncommon to find black eggs in general. Even the top egg-laying chickens rarely produce eggs with this unique yolk color.

Typically, egg yolks range from light yellow to deep orange, depending on the chicken’s diet and breed. 

Generally, the diet of a chicken can influence yolk color, with certain feeds potentially darkening the yolk. However, these dietary changes usually result in yolks that are greenish or grayish, not black. 

As we mentioned earlier, black yolks are the result of external factors such as chemical reactions or contamination occurring after the egg has been laid.

In some rare cases, genetic factors or health issues in chickens might also lead to unusual yolk colors. Yet, even in these instances, black yolks are not a common outcome. 

As such, if you encounter a black yolk, it’s probably due to changes that happen outside of the chicken’s body after the egg is laid.

Did this comprehensive guide on black egg yolk satisfy your curiosity? Share your thoughts, experiences, and questions on black egg yolks in the comments!

Leave a Comment

You may also like